WorldNavalShips .com Home Page
Order Enquiries (UK) : 01436 820269

You currently have no items in your basket

Naval History by Country :
ROYAL
NAVY
US
NAVY
GERMAN
NAVY
FRENCH
NAVY
MORE
PAGES
VIEW ALL OF OUR CURRENT ART SPECIAL OFFERS ON ONE PAGE HERE
NAVAL ART AVIATION ART MILITARY ART SPORT ART
Ship Search by Name :
Product Search         
ALWAYS GREAT OFFERS :
20% FURTHER PRICE REDUCTIONS ON HUNDREDS OF LIMITED EDITION ART PRINTS
BUY ONE GET ONE HALF PRICE ON THOUSANDS OF PAINTINGS AND PRINTS
FOR MORE OFFERS SIGN UP TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
HM Submarine Poseidon - World Naval Ships Forums Archive (Page 3)


HM Submarine Poseidon (Page 3)


Posts 101 to 150



A great pictorial record - Excellent viewing!! Many thanks Little h


Hi Kc. BZ again.These are supurb and so clear,as stated whoever took them was a fine photographer.My wife always asks what the insides of the older Boats looked like as she's only been onboard Nukes.Now I can show her. Thanks again..Regards ..Steve.


Unbelievable. The clarity is superb. Having these photos is like creating a technical record of the Parthian-class boats. Interesting to see Poseidon's torpedo tubes up close. I got a look at Perseus's last summer when I dived the wreck off of Greece. Now the tubes are home to moray eels. Thanks KC. You have done this community and naval historians in general a great service by acquiring this collection and making it available online.


I would still be extremely interested to talk with either CPO Patrick Henry Willis's daughter Julia or his son, whose name I do not know. Their father is the hero of the Poseidon story and deserves a bit greater exposure in the book, given the general dearth of information about him.


Please join the Facebook group for "The Real Poseidon Adventure: China's Secret Salvage of Britain's Lost Submarine" for all the updates on the book's publication and author event dates: [url]http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=353018157504&ref=mf[/url] Follow hmsposeidon on Twitter: [url]http://www.twitter.com/hmsposeidon[/url]


The temporary site for the book is now up. Please visit: [url]http://www.hmsposeidon.com[/url]


Hi, may I know where is the grave stone? MTang from Hong Kong


Sadly the gravestones were removed decades ago.


Here is another link to HMS Poseidon. My uncle, Leading Seaman Frank Dowling, was one of the 18 who went down in Poseidon. He is wrongly listed as P Dowling. I was shocked to learn about the "salvage" of Poseidon and to hear that no human remains had been found. Previously I had the good fortune to meet Nancy Bevan, step daughter of Capt. Marrack, who had been in Wei Hai Wei at the time of the disaster and had many photographs. She told me "Wei Hai Wei was the holiday paradise of the world". Looking up modern WeiHai on the internet and seeing that it has around 2.5 million population, very different to the 30's, it was reassuring to read that even now it has the reputation of being "a fairy isle on the sea" and "a Garden of Eden". More than anything I want to visit WeiHai and it would be wonderful if something could be arranged for the 80th anniversary next year. Has anyone been there? Linda Matthews


I have just seen with interest the pic of the memorial for Poseidon. Can you explain why not all the men who perished are listed and also where this memorial was sited? Many thanks Linda M


Linda, Who seems to be missing from the listings on the stones?


In your message of 16.08.2009 you showed a picture of a Memorial to crew lost in Poseidon. At the head of the stone it said "In memory of Albert R Winter, Stoker, Survivor of HMS Poseidon, died 9 June 1931, and then listed 9 further names: A V Paine, H Cliff, E G Gaines, R C Bowers, F T Pointer, W Whitley, F C Tolliday, A Gray, C J Beaumont On 30.08.2009 you listed "what you had from your file on 'lost' submariners". "Commemorated in the Cemetery Wei Hai Wei": In memory of Arthur J Lovock, Able Seaman, Survivor of HMS Poseidon, died 9th June 1931 also of G C Hews, A D Collings, A J Bagley, S Sherrocks, W R Pyne, F Dowling, R Balshaw, T V Grills, W H H Pike. Please can you clarify whether these are two separate Memorials or are the names listed on both sides of the Memorial in the pic? And presumably the Memorial is one that has disappeared? Many thanks


Problem solved. After listing the names of the men whose names did not appear on the memorial stone, I wondered again what had become of the framed photograph of a memorial which my aunt had in her possession. After a lot of turning out I found it! A black framed photograph inscribed, "Presented by the Submarine and Royal Air Force Personnel in China, 1931-32. In Memory of their Comrades". It shows a large squarish area covered in stones with a stone/granite border and two memorial stones on plinths side by side. Each was headed with the name of one of the men who escaped and died, followed by the names of nine of those who perished in the Poseidon. It appears to be set in a cemetery, overlooking the sea (perhaps a bay) with hilly landscape on the far side. The picture was framed by J. W. Mills, Fine Art Dealer, of Portsmouth. I am endeavouring to get a clear image to post.


After some help from my husband, managed to find how to put the image here for all to see! [url]http://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76550&stc=1&d=1272205477[/url]
Attachments :



LINDA, here are details of Submarine Service & loss of L/Sea Dowling ; DOWLING FRANK LDG SEA C/J 106162 NE RN SM POSEIDON 09.06.31 Y 25 180406 C D F P WEI HAI WEI GLR 16 HMS MEDWAY. ADM 104 / 112. Record 6074 / 31. Page 240. Wei Hai Wei. At sea. Drowning. Sinking of S/M POSEIDON. H.M. Submarine POSEIDON was in collision with the Chinese steamer YUTA off Wei Hai Wei, on the `China Station'. 20 of the crew of POSEIDON were lost, along with a Chinese `Officers Steward'. JS 270530. HMS MEDWAY. The captain Lt.Cdr Bernard Galpin survived the collision. Commemorated in the Cemetery Wei Hai Wei ; Inscription on Grave-stone of A.J. LOVOCK reads ; IN MEMORY OF ARTHUR J. LOVOCK, ABLE SEAMAN SURVIVOR OF H.M.S. POSEIDON DIED 9th JUNE 1931 ALSO OF T.V. GRILLS, PETTY OFFICER W.H. PIKE, E.R.A. F. DOWLING, LEADING SEAMAN D. SHERROCKS, LEADING STOKER G.C. HEWS, ABLE SEAMAN A.D. COLLINGS, ABLE SEAMAN A.J. BAGLEY, STOKER W.R. PYNE, STOKER R. BALSHAW, STOKER LOST WITH POSEIDON AT SEA Photographs of the grave are available in the R.N.S.M. TC 300527 DOLPHIN ADDL 300725 POSEIDON 301031 DOLPHIN POSEIDON 301212 MEDWAY DD 310609 POSEIDON VICE LOCKELL Sadsac


Dennis, many thanks for the confirmation regarding the memorials. I am attaching some pics and some more queries! Perhaps you or others on the forum might be able to help. Many thanks. Linda [IMG]http://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76560&stc=1&d=1272215940[/IMG] After my first meeting with Nancy Bevan, and the excitement of looking at her photo albums, I received this photo which she had cut out of her album. It shows Poseidon, with presumably the crew boarding boats to go out to the submarine. Huge crowds of military on the shore and a faded title read "The Army and Navy". Was this a special occasion? Does anyone know more? [IMG]http://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76561&stc=1&d=1272215940[/IMG] A photograph sent by Frank Dowling to his wife, Vera along with several others of Chinese life. This shows HMS Medway with the submarines alongside in Hong Kong 1931. [IMG]http://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76562&stc=1&d=1272215940[/IMG] Frank Dowling and a pal from HMS Vernon who could possibly be a brother-in-law - can anyone confirm his rank? Frank has a blazer badge (which I found amongst my aunt's treasured possessions) and I am curious to know if it relates to submarines or the Navy. It is shown in the next picture. [IMG]http://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76563&stc=1&d=1272215940[/IMG]
Attachments :



Hi Linda.The mans rank in photo #3 is Leading seaman,with three Good Conduct Badges. Regards Steve.


Many thanks Steve and I shall hope to track down whether he is an uncle of mine. Linda


Linda, the VERNON rating is also a LTO - Leading Torpedo Opperator. Sadsac


Many thanks Dennis, this is excellent - more information all the time and it is much appreciated. Linda


[QUOTE=Elizabeth ann Halsall;60346]My father John Edward Halsall, was a survivor of the HMS Poseidon, Known as Jack. Elizabeth Halsall.[/QUOTE] Dear Elizabeth As a new member of the Forum I just wanted to make contact with you. My uncle was Frank Dowling, one of the unfortunate men who perished in HMS Poseidon. I hope you are still looking at the Forum as there is so much fascinating information and wonderful pictures. Linda


[QUOTE=Linda Matthews;112319]After some help from my husband, managed to find how to put the image here for all to see! [url]http://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76550&stc=1&d=1272205477[/url][/QUOTE] Hi Linda Nice photos, especially the one of the memorials! The graveyard is the one we visited on Liugong island. It is all now very overgrown, all the gravestones appear to have been removed long ago and it has a 6 foot high wall around it, so Doreen and I laid a second wreath on the outside of the wall approximately where the memorial stones were originally. The removal of the gravestones and the wall led me to believe at first that local Chinese govt. were involved in somehow trying to remove traces of British rule, but I have heard reports of signs of some gravestones being reused as building materials on the island. I would imagine that building materials would be expensive to transport by boat from the mainland, so it now seems just as likely that the locals pinched the stonework and the wall was perhaps built to keep them out! I have no doubt that the bodies are all still buried there. The island is now some sort of cadet training base by the look of it. A road link was being built when we visited last year, so I don't know what will happen to the cemetery if the Chinese start to develop the island.


Linda, the Blazer Badge looks a little like the castle that is depicted for Gibraltar - as in its defence. Only a guess mind you. Perhaps you may do better to put it into the Badges / Crests Thread in the `Everything Else' Dept. If difficult PM TERRY / Clive they will no doubt be of assistance. Sadsac


:)I am speechless at the clarity of these photographs [see post#79] and especialy the two that clearly name A J Lovock. This is my wife's uncle and I do have a small photo of him in uniform but these are something else. Thank you to all who have made them available the family will treasure them. Luck of the Irish at last. regards Shamrock


Survivor Signalman Fred Grabham, who appears in a number of these photos, is my father. He was on the bridge at the time and the transcript I have of his evidence to the Court of Enquiry is as follows: "At diving stations I came on the bridge and noticed the "Yuta" on the port bow (about 40 to 50 degrees) about a mile away. The Captain was on the starboard side standing on the step, I was on the port side by the hatch. I saw him moving the azimuth on the Sperry repeater on the foremast periscope. He spoke down the voice pipe and I heard him say something like "No 1 if I were you I would turn away from the Marazim (own submarine tender ship) to get a good run at her. There is a ship close on your port but you have plenty of room to clear her. Hard a starboard." The Captain sounded two blasts and got up on the step again. I saw the wheel turn to port. I watched the "Yuta" and saw the forward W/T (wireless/telegraph) tripod pass across her. The Captain then crossed over to the port side and crossed to the starboard side to continue watching the "Yuta". The "Yuta" bore in on the starboard bow (10 to 20 degrees) when I saw her start swinging to starboard. The Captain immediately lent across and sounded the hooter twice again. The "Yuta" continued to swing to starboard and did not seem to check her way at all. When full astern was ordered by the captain, I turned round and put both telegraphs full astern together. I think the time between Full Astern and the crash was about 7 1/2 minutes. The captain ordered close W/T (watertight) doors. Then shortly (about 1/2 min) before the collision "All hands on deck". He also ordered "Blow A.B.Y.Z.". The "Yuta" hit us at slightly more than right angles and seemed to be going just as fast as ever." The transcript of Signalman F.F.J..GRABHAM's subsequent cross examination at the Court of Enquiry reads :- 1 (Q) When the Captain said to the First Lieutenant "There is a ship on your port bow", did he also say "You have plenty of room to turn clear of her"? (A) Yes. 2 (Q) Are you absolutely certain that when the "Yuta" altered course to starboard that she was well on "Poseidon's starboard bow? (A) Positive 3 (Q) When the Captain ordered full speed astern can you remember how the "Yuta" was pointing at you? (A) She appeared to be coming straight for us. 4 (Q) When the Captain ordered "Hard a starboard" was there any idea in your mind that there was a risk of a collision or that you were in any way standing in danger? (A) Not in the slightest. 5 (Q) How long have you known Lieutenant Commander Bernard Galpin ? (A) I served under him in H.M.S/M L 11 and Poseidon, about two and a half years. 6 (Q) Have you complete confidence in him as a captain of a submarine? (A) Perfect. 7 (Q) Are you prepared to serve under him again in submarines if given the opportunity. (A) Yes certainly." Fred was recalled back to the navy just before WW2 broke out and served on Atlantic convoys and in the Mediterranean. As a Leading Signalman he was on the Hunt Class destroyer HMS Derwent for the breakthrough Malta Convoy. Back in civilian life he just would never fly but when asked in 1952 if he would ever go down again in a submarine again, his somewhat surprising reply after all that happened was "Yes tomorrow if I had the chance" Fred Grabham's daughter, Ruth Grabham (now Mrs Ruth Peate, Auckland, NZ)


Wife is daughter of survivor of HM Sub. 'Poseidon's 1931 disaster.


Thank you very much Ruth for sharing the transcript with us, I found it most informative. Bob.


Despeate ?? What was the survivors name & what (if any) information do you require. Sadsac


[QUOTE=dennis a feary;126170]Despeate ?? What was the survivors name & what (if any) information do you require. Sadsac[/QUOTE] My father was Signalman Frederick Francis James Grabham (Fred) - refer previous post #125. We already have quite a good account of his part. His long Naval career started when he went to Greenwich Naval School in 1912 at the age of 10, signed up when he turned 15 then volunteered for submarines in 1925. Ruth Peate.


[FONT=Verdana]This excellent thread has many links to sources describing the tragic incident between [I]Poseidon[/I] and the [I]Yuta[/I], but for the sake of completeness, I thought it would be fitting to just give a short summary about this submarine and her fate.[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon [/FONT][FONT=Verdana](99P) was the second boat of the Parthian Class of submarines to be launched. The Parthian boats were quite similar to the previous ‘O’ Class, but had a raked bow, and a shield fitted round the 4 inch gun. They also were able to achieve a higher speed, both on the surface, and whilst submerged. Like the ‘O’ boats, they had had saddle tanks for some of their fuel, which when submerged and under pressure, tended to leak, leaving a tell tale trace on the surface.[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]The boats in this Class were, in order of launch:[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS [I]Perseus[/I] (36P, 36N, N36)[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS[I] Poseidon[/I] (99P)[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS [I]Parthian[/I] (75P, 75N, N75)[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS [I]Proteus[/I] (29P, 29N, N29)[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS [I]Pandora[/I] (42P, 42N)[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]HMS [I]Phoenix[/I] (96P, 96N, N96)[/FONT] [I][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon[/FONT][/I][FONT=Verdana] was built by Vickers, Barrow (yard number 639). She was launched on [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]the 21st June 1929[/FONT][FONT=Verdana], by the wife of Vice Admiral Vernon Haggard, and commissioned in March 1930 for operations in the [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]China[/FONT][FONT=Verdana]Seas[/FONT][FONT=Verdana].[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]On [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]the 9th of June 1931[/FONT][FONT=Verdana], [I]Poseidon[/I] was taking part in exercises with the submarine tender HMS [I]Marazion[/I] in the [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]Bohai[/FONT][FONT=Verdana]Sea[/FONT][FONT=Verdana], some twenty miles north of her home base at Wei Hai Wei on the north East Coast of the Shan-tung peninsula, [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]China[/FONT][FONT=Verdana].[/FONT] [FONT=Verdana]At around [/FONT][FONT=Verdana]12.45 pm[/FONT][FONT=Verdana], the submarine collided with the Chinese merchant ship SS [I]Yuta[/I], whose bow carved a v-shaped gash in [I]Poseidon[/I]’s saddle tanks. The order was immediately given to abandon ship and thirty men managed to scramble clear before the submarine plunged to the seabed 130 feet below, just two minutes after the collision. Five of these survivors were picked up by the nearby HMS [I]Herme[/I]s.[/FONT] [I][COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon[/FONT][/COLOR][/I][COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana] was equipped with DSEA (Davis Submerged Escape Apparatus) which had come into service two years earlier. This was a closed circuit underwater breathing system which provided the wearer with a supply of pure oxygen and a canvas drogue to slow the rate of ascent. Despite the submarine not being equipped with specialised escape compartments or flooding valves, eight of the crew managed to leave via a bow compartment, although two failed to reach the surface and one died later. A total of 22 crew died, 18 of which remained on board the sunken submarine.[/FONT][/COLOR] [COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon_1: Poseidon [I](postcard from my personal collection)[/I][/FONT][/COLOR] [COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon_2: Poseidon alongside depot ship [I](postcard from my personal collection)[/I][/FONT][/COLOR] [COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Posiedon_3: Newspaper (unknown) article, [/FONT][/COLOR][COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]June 19th 1931[/FONT][/COLOR] [COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon_4: Daily Herald headlines, June 10th[/FONT][/COLOR] [COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]Poseidon_5: Launch of [I]Poseidon[/I], Vickers, Barrow, [/FONT][/COLOR][COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana]21st June 1929[/FONT][/COLOR][COLOR=black][FONT=Verdana] ([I]source of original photograph unknown)[/I][/FONT][/COLOR] Poseidon_6: Illustrated London News, July 18th 1931 [FONT=Verdana][COLOR=white].[/COLOR][/FONT] [FONT=Verdana][COLOR=white].[/COLOR][/FONT] [FONT=Verdana][COLOR=white].[/COLOR][/FONT]
Attachments :



An excellent summary Clive with some great postcards and clippings to boot. Very many thanks. :)


Dreadnought thank you for the pics. I do not recall seeing the excellent PC of Poseidon before, nor the one of the launching of Poseidon. All help to expand my family history relating to my uncle, Frank Dowling. Best regards Linda M


Linda Two more photos which may be of interest. Regards gerry
Attachments :



Many thanks Gerry. I have seen the "In Memory" card before and believe these were sold to raise money for the survivors and the familes of those who perished. Joining the Forum has produced such rich results, particularly with photographs, and contact with other family members. The 80th anniversary next year will be a very significant event. Best regards Linda


HMS Poseidon families: UK Prime Minister is visiting Beijing next week. Suggest you call the Prime Minister's office and ask him to raise the subject of the remains of the HMS Poseidon crew during his visit. He's going to talk about Chinese dissident/Nobel Prize winner Liu Xiaobo; why not talk about British servicemen?


Thanks for this useful suggestion which I have sadly picked up too late. However, I am poised to contact Jeremy Browne MP, whose responsibilities at the FCO include SE Asia and the Far East. I understand from Steve Schwankert that there is a memorial garden at the British Embassy in Beijing, with plaques and monuments to British servicemen and women who died in China and whose bodies were not recovered. I agree with him that this could be the place for a Poseidon memorial. If others with family connections to Poseidon are reading this you may like to know that Steve has offered to begin co-ordinating the families to petition the government to create and post a plaque or memorial at the Embassy. In the meantime Jeremy B may well advise me of the best course of action from this end. With the 80th anniversary of the disaster in 2011 it is time to act.


Families and Friends of HMS Poseidon: First of all let me thank everyone who has contributed material to the HMS Poseidon book. The final manuscript is going out the door before New Year's Eve, and it will be a great relief. That said, I wanted to give the material all the time it deserved -- and it deserved every moment of the five years I worked on it. In late January and early February I will be visiting the U.K. The primary reason is to give a presentation on HMS Poseidon at the International Shipwreck Conference [[url]www.shipwreckconference.org][/url] in Plymouth on Feb. 5. I will also be presenting to branches of the Submariners Association in Barrow and Gosport, on Feb. 1 and Feb. 3, respectively. I would like to organize an opportunity for the Poseidon family members to gather in Gosport during the weekend of Jan. 29-30. Tentative schedule would be Friday evening arrival and dinner; Saturday morning presentation about the sinking and the salvage; lunch; Saturday afternoon tour of the Royal Navy Submarine Museum; dinner; Sunday breakfast and departure. Aside from the above, this would give family members a chance to meet, and also to discuss issues such as preparing a Poseidon memorial for the U.K. embassy in Beijing's memorial garden, where other servicemen and women lost in China are remembered. Please contact me directly if you'd like to attend. The event is open to direct relatives of Poseidon crewmen. You are also welcome to attend the Shipwreck Conference in Plymouth on Feb. 5.


This story just keeps getting better and better: [url]http://www.lep.co.uk/community/nostalgia_2_1892/help_me_trace_my_lost_family_1_2887426[/url] Published on Tue Dec 28 10:02:06 GMT 2010 A grandfather is looking for information about his father who was a survivor of the doomed submarine HMS Poseidon. Jack Halsall, 80, a grandfather-of-eight, has dozens of photos and newspaper cuttings about his father who was one of the 30 surviving crew members who escaped the ill-fated submarine, when it collided with the Chinese merchant steamer SS Yuta on 9 June 1931. But when he returned from sea, Jack believes his father started a new family in Northern Ireland, and is desperate to track down any living relatives. He said: “I was told about my dad from an early age. I knew he was on the Poseidon, and on my birth certificate it says Able Seaman John Edward Halsall. “I didn’t know him, but I’d be interested to know a bit more. He was stationed in China but I have only just found this out. “When I was in Hong Kong doing my National Service I had a feeling I had been there before – it was strange. I feel like there is a missing link.” Jack was told his father jumped off the submarine as it collided with the fishing boat, grabbing hold of a rope. He has came close to tracking down his family when he found a woman called Elizabeth Ann Halsall searching for information about her father on the internet. The woman had posted on the World Naval Ships forum. Jack believes the woman may be his half-sister. He said: “There was a rumour my dad had gone to Birmingham, but he ended up in Ireland.” To help Jack trace his missing family, contact [email]rachel.dearden@lep.co.uk[/email].


[url]http://www.submarine-museum.co.uk/news/321-the-real-poseidon-adventure-chinas-secret-salvage-of-britains-lost-[/url] Saturday 29th January 1.30pm A talk by award winning writer Steven Schwankert A rare opportunity to catch Steven while he is here in the UK to tell the newly discovered history of HMS Poseidon, a Royal Navy Parthian-class submarine that sank in a collision on June 9, 1931. Steven is a professional diver and award-winning writer with almost 15 years' experience in China. Tickets: Free (does not include a tour of HMS Alliance) No booking necessary.


[QUOTE=Dreadnought;129208]Poseidon_2: Poseidon alongside depot ship (postcard from my personal collection)[/QUOTE] Does anyone know the identity of the depot ship in that 2nd picture? It looks like a converted old warship, perhaps an ex-cruiser, sloop or gunboat. I don't think I've seen it before.


Hi Linux, I believe the Depot Ship appearing in that photo is HMS Ambrose which served on The China Station in association with Tender Ship HMS Marazion which was exercising with the Poseidon when tragedy struck. HMS Ambrose was a 1903 6,450 ton merchant ship which was converted in 1915 to a Submarine Depot Ship and served in WW1. It remained on the effective list until 1938 but before the start of WW2 was renamed HMS Cochrane. During that war it served as a submarine Harbour Depot Ship and was finally scrapped in 1949 at Inverkeithing.


A small post script. This ship was handed over to the Firth of Forth yard for breaking up as "ss Ambrose" and the year was 1946 rather than 1949.


Thank you for your reply. Looking at pictures of HMS Ambrose it is difficult to believe they are the same ship! In particular the "mystery" ship above seems to be lacking the amidships superstructure visible on HMS Ambrose. Also the "mystery" ship seems to have its mainmast immediately abaft the funnel, whereas HMS Ambrose had it further aft.


Hi Linux Could you be looking at a photo of the subsequent HMS Ambrose depot ship which took over the same name ? This certainly was a larger vessel with a more prominent superstructure. The mast that appears to be just aft of the funnel in photo No 2 is, I feel, simply that of another entirely different ship tied up on the opposite side of the depot ship. I have downloaded a smallish photo of the earlier HMS Ambrose which corresponds very well and I think will convince you. However before passing it on will have a search for any others. Regards


Hello. As far as I know I am looking at photos of the ship purchased in 1915, converted to a submarine depot ship from 1915-1917, commissioned in 1917, renamed Cochrane in 1938, and broken up in 1946. So that would cover the period of Poseidon's short life from 1930-1931. An example is attached.


... Sorry, forgot to hit the "Upload" button!
Attachments :



[QUOTE=linux;155349]Hello. As far as I know I am looking at photos of the ship purchased in 1915, converted to a submarine depot ship from 1915-1917, commissioned in 1917, renamed Cochrane in 1938, and broken up in 1946. So that would cover the period of Poseidon's short life from 1930-1931. An example is attached.[/QUOTE] Hello again, Have searched for a 1930s photo of the Ambrose taken from the other side to correspond with the Photo 2 angle but not luck so far. As you will know depot ships had a repair/maintenance function so opposite sides were often fitted out quite differently and were frequently altered as new equipment and ideas came into being. The attached small image is unfortunately from a similar angle to your camouflaged one so doesn't prove or disprove anything. Have searched the [url]www.battleships-cruiser.co.uk/depot_ships[/url] website and have been unable to find a better match and the Submariners Assoc website [url]www.rnsubs.co.uk[/url] tells us the following about the Ambrose. [U]Quote[/U]:Before the start of WWII she was re named HMS Cochrane. Converted 20th October 1915.Served during world war one and removed from the effective list in 1938 but saw service in World war two as a Harbour depot ship for submarines.Displacement: 6480 tons,Length: 387ft 9in,Beam: 47ft 6in,Draught: 20ft 6in,Speed: 14.5 knots,Armament: Two 12PDR,Compliment: 238. Tenders: [B][U]Marazion[/U][/B] + 1 drifter. [U]Unquote[/U]. I feel the last line is significant as the Marazion was exercising with the Poseidon when it all happened and the Ambrose is down as being attached to the China Station. Anyone else got a better idea ?
Attachments :



Thanks for that. I don't think our "mystery" ship is HMS Marazion, since the former has a flush deck whereas HMS Marazion had a raised forecastle (or at least a bulwark around the forecastle). And again HMS Marazion had some amidships superstructure. I can believe our "mystery" ship is an unknown drifter though. Another source of information about depot ships (among others) is Warlow's [I]Shore Establishments of the Royal Navy: Being a list of the Static Ships and Establishments of the Royal Navy[/I]. It gives a somewhat terse service history for every such ship. Problem is, without knowing the name of the "mystery" ship, it's going to be a laborious job trying to find its entry in the book! By the way, I landed on this page precisely because I was searching for information about HMS Marazion. A nice postcard turned up on eBay and I had never heard of it being a submarine depot ship. Alas there seems to be no single authoritative work on Royal Navy depot ships, though I vaguely recall reading a year or two back that a new book from the World Ship Society was in the works.


The ship in the second photo of post#130 is a "24" class minesweeping sloop; she has another vessel on her port side, whose foremast and bridge are visible above the sloop's foc's'le. As to which of the class, some references (Wikipedia, so must be true :D) say only four of the class had their mast abaft the funnel - I've seen pictures captioned LADAS, ORMONDE, SILVIO and SIR BEVIS with this configuration. Tim


Warlow describes HMS Ladas thus: [QUOTE]LADAS (1918) Gosport, SM DS Sloop, sold 1920, re-purch as mooring vessel Gosport 1920, DS 5 SM Gosport 1930 till sold 08.36[/QUOTE] "DS" is depot ship, "SM" is submarine, "5 SM" is 5th submarine flotilla / squadron. Ormonde and Silvio are not listed in the book. Sir Bevis is listed as becoming a training ship. So HMS Ladas would be a good candidate for our "mystery" ship. And another depot ship can be added to the list! Thank you very much.




Previous Posts

More Posts


Everything we obtain for this site is shown on the site, we do not have any more photos, crew lists or further information on any of the ships.

COPYRIGHT NOTICE. ALL IMAGES DISPLAYED ON THIS WEBSITE ARE PROTECTED BY  COPYRIGHT  LAW, AND ARE OWNED BY CRANSTON FINE ARTS OR THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS.  NO REPRODUCTION OR COPYING ALLOWED ON OTHER WEBSITES, BOOKS OR ARTICLES WITHOUT PRIOR AGREEMENT.

Contact Details
Shipping Info
Terms and Conditions
Cookie Policy
Privacy Policy

Join us on Facebook!

Sign Up To Our Newsletter!

Stay up to date with all our latest offers, deals and events as well as new releases and exclusive subscriber content!

This website is owned by Cranston Fine Arts.  Torwood House, Torwoodhill Road, Rhu, Helensburgh, Scotland, G848LE

Contact: Tel: (+44) (0) 1436 820269.  Email: cranstonorders -at- outlook.com

Follow us on Twitter!

Return to Home Page