PDA

View Full Version : Review: The British Pacific Fleet by David Hobbs


Andy H
26-08-2011, 12:31
The British Pacific Fleet: The Royal Navy’s Most Powerful Strike Force by David Hobbs.
Published by Seaforth, ISBN 978184320482

Many of us are now well acquainted with the term ‘The Forgotten Army’ and how this relates to the rather neglected topic of the British 14th Army and its campaigns and battles in Burma, India and beyond. The British naval equivalent is the ‘British Pacific Fleet’ (BPF) of late 1944 and up to the end of the war against Japan. The BPF like the British 14th Army was the most powerful/largest force of its type that this country had put together in WW2.

Hobbs manages with ease to tell the tale of the BPF’s rather runt like birth and the huge challenges it faced just to be accepted as an equal by the battle hardened USN in the Pacific theatre. The often overlooked part played by the Commonwealth nations is given due credit, for without its logistical contribution above all else, the BPF would have remained but an ideal at best or a shadow of its reality at worst.

The book is broken down into some 16 easily definable chapters, from its background through to its evolution and expansion, thence into its first faltering operational steps. From these less than stellar beginnings we see how contrary to belief the Royal Navy could adapt quickly and indeed improve on the experience and information provided by the USN. The all important logistical tail and fleet train are given due credence & gravitas, as we see the zone of operations for the BPF grow in both size and importance. The political dimension is duly covered and a warts n all narrative leaves the reader in no doubt how the BPF leadership rose to the challenges placed before it by a rather sceptical and even at times hostile USN. From this honest approach by both primary nations we can see how finally the BPF was forged into an effective Task Force serving alongside the powerful USN.

As one would expect with such a book it is suitably furnished with plenty of B/W photographs and maps, with an equally well furnished appendices and bibliography to boot.

This new pinnacle book by David Hobbs paints a picture that will enrapture its reader through its sheer detail and narrative eloquence. Whereas in the past students have reached for copies of H P Willmot and P Smith, they will now seek out this work by David Hobbs.

Regards

Don Boyer
27-08-2011, 00:03
Thanks for that timely review, Andy. I have been awaiting comment from a knowledgeable forum member before casting my hard-earned cash onto the web to get the book, which is No. 1 on my list of this year's "gotta have's." Being a Pacific war fan, I've not had one on the BPF in the fold yet.

Regards,

Hugh Williams
27-08-2011, 07:44
Thanks for the review. I have bought the book and found it to be full of detail and a good read nevertheless, as sometimes the detail can edge out the 'readability'. This book is an absolute must as part of the RN's war history. It has an unfortunate consequence - I enjoyed the narrative that much I am minded to buy David Hobbs' other works, so off to the Finance Minister for concurrence with the scheme (new book case)!

A fully recommended book for any person who is interested in RN history and which deals with our relationship with the US Navy in the Pacific.

Regards,

Hugh Williams

sheldon
27-08-2011, 11:07
I have considered purchasing this book but I wonder if it is worth parting with my cash.
I find John Winton's book "The Forgotten Fleet" to be a most comprehansive account of the Naval War in the Pacific and coupled with one of David Hobbs other books "Moving Bases", I'd like to think I have a complete overview of the war.
Would this book be a worthy addition to these book or just a repeat of information?

Hugh Williams
02-09-2011, 17:53
I have considered purchasing this book but I wonder if it is worth parting with my cash.
I find John Winton's book "The Forgotten Fleet" to be a most comprehansive account of the Naval War in the Pacific and coupled with one of David Hobbs other books "Moving Bases", I'd like to think I have a complete overview of the war.
Would this book be a worthy addition to these book or just a repeat of information?
I was wondering about those books myself........